you are right, families are different so just cuz it didn't affect me or my siblings or friends adversely, doesn't mean it's the same for all. i guess if a kid really takes it to heart and as an adult thinks it has a negative effect on their own actions decades later, then it has had a negative effect on them. i don't know if the spank would be the sole factor in that though. as you've suggested, my dad could put the fear of god in me simply by a tone of voice and a look - an icy stare that meant ohhhh shit i'd better behave!
i'm not insisting on the use of spankings by any means. if you can avoid it, that's good. i just felt the need to respond (incredulously) that if i'm not appalled by the azz smack, it doesn't equal being a violent child, wife, and pet beater which some here claim. well, hopefully their kids, spouses and pets will behave around me now at least ...also i'm sure your kid is great and i know lots of good parents and kids, plenty on this board too. my "kids these days/back in my day..." rant in crotchety old voice...hmmm maybe i've been hanging out with someone too long i hear stories all the time from teachers that make me cringe. lots of kids today are dictators and control their teachers and parents, not the other way around!
anyway, you are a smart and thoughtful poster and your response makes me consider the other view a lot more than "you're nothing but a wife beater and probably drive drunk too" nonsense. thank you.