Rolling Stone's 50 Best Albums of 2005

[Jaimoe]

http://www.rollingstone.com/special/8952414

[Booche]

Havent seen you on here in a while. I bet it's because the Leaves suck.

[AD]

without getting specific, i'll argue that that list is bullshit

ad

[Jaimoe]

Havent seen you on here in a while. I bet it's because the Leaves suck.

I've been busy going to Christmas parties and writing a John Fogerty CD review.

[Blane]

where's Shine?

edit: I must shamefully confess that Illinois is the only album on the list that I've even heard.

Edited December 20, 2005 by Guest

[dimafleck: the living legend.]

dude...

frances the mute should be way higher than fucking 24...espeicially considering some of the albums ahead of it.

best album of 2005 in my opinion.

[Jaimoe]

I 'almost' bought Booche a couple albums listed in the Top 10 for his Christmas present.

[Guest Low Roller]

The only album that Booche truly deserves to get for Christmas is #1.

It's the equivalent of a lump of coal.

[Booche]

HEY EVERYBODY!

LOW ROLLER IS A FUCKING IDIOT!!!

[NewRider]

good to see Kings of Leon made the list.

[dave-O]

Considering it's coming from Rolling Stone, I don't think that list is too bad. Springsteen, MMJ, Beck, Bright Eyes and Sufjan all cracked the top 10. Hell even Stars made it on there at #50.

[MarcO]

is Booche still a moderator?

if so, why?

[Booche]

Hey MarcO, I got an Xmas present for ya!

[jayr]

Thelonious Monk & Coltrane @ #14. WOW!! Hard to imagine Kanye West getting more props than Coltrane & Monk. The world of pop music makes me ill. Talent means nothing if you've got a cool look or big tits but it makes sense now that you don't have to pay for cd's anymore, most aren't even worth wasting a blank disc on. Thank god there are still talented people out there. I wonder what that list would look like if it was the 50 most talented of 2005? Sorry for the ramble.......

by the way

BECK

WHITE STRIPES

MARS VOLTA and a couple others truly deserve to be on there.

Edited December 20, 2005 by Guest
ramble not long enough

[ollie]

I'm dumbfounded by the Rolling Stones at #2. The lazy write-up makes it an even worse choice. WTF?!

[Guest Low Roller]

HEY EVERYBODY!

LOW ROLLER IS A FUCKING IDIOT!!!

No I'm not.

[questcequecest?]

They claim you don't know what you got 'till its gone,

I know I got it, I don't know what y'all on.

#1, wow!

[Patchoulia]

Aren't the Gorrilaz a fake cartoon band a la The Archies?

That's just fabulous.